06 November 2017 0 Comments Posted By : Justin McElroy

Should historic racism against Chinese-Canadians be enough to kill new Chinatown condo?

Those who think a government apology for past wrongs is automatically good PR should have been at Vancouver City Hall on Wednesday. 

Members of the Chinese-Canadian community came to show support for a unanimous motion that will have the city officially apologize for racist laws and policies enacted in the early 1900s.

And while some focused on the apology itself, others explicitly linked a historic apology with the nine-storey market housing condo proposed for 105 Keefer Street in the heart of Chinatown.

They say the project destroys the one place in the city where their relatives found safety and solace from racism.

Racism is at the heart of the most powerful argument those against the tower have been making, which made for an interesting juxtaposition at council.

George Ing, an 85-year-old who served in the Canadian Armed Forces for 35 years, spoke about a childhood where his parents couldn't vote and he was told regularly to "keep his head down."

Cynthia Kent said her mother was the first full-time public school teacher in Vancouver of Chinese descent but she was prohibited from taking a lifesaving course required for her job because the city's only public indoor pool banned Chinese people.

Kent said an apology would represent a stepping stone for greater reconciliation.

Marielle Wall wants more than an apology from city officials 

"An apology doesn't save Chinatown," she said. "It doesn't give me back my culture. An apology with no action is just retraumatizing the people who come to speak each time a new apology is given."

Wall was one of three consecutive speakers who spent as much time in front of council talking about how 105 Keefer  needs to be rejected than past policies towards Chinese Canadians.

"Actions need to be taken to save Chinatown, so children like me can see and love our culture — actions like rejecting 105 Keefer Street and re-buying the land to give to our current elders, who are facing similar displacement and racism."

That's the thrust of why there's been more passion around 105 Keefer than countless other towers that get approved in Metro Vancouver every month.

Judging by the non-plussed reaction by councillors to Wall's plea, it's unclear whether they accept the argument.  

More than a parking lot

From the outside, it might seem curious that so many meetings and protests have been devoted to a Vancouver parking lot being replaced by a mid-sized tower. 

But the debate over 105 Keefer isn't just another in the long line of condo controversies. Criticisms of a development approval process usually seen as symbolic of nine years of Vision Vancouver governance, become symbolic of 150 years of discrimination.

"We're talking about historical discrimination? We're talking about two days ago, where we stayed until midnight having our turn to speak [against 105 Keefer], and where there was no translation provided," said Andrea Lum.

Lum was referring to a permit board hearing on Oct. 30 that ended with no resolution to the controversy. 

Coun. Kerry Jang, whose grandfather was a pig farmer in China, said he understands why some Chinatown residents equate the proposed condo project with past wrongs, even though he doesn't personally agree with it.

"It's a change of place they associate with the Chinese community. But as I've always said the Chinese community itself has changed," Jang said.

"One of the consequences of multiculturalism of course is that the old ethnic enclaves are taking on less of a relevance in some ways."

views : 127 | images : 1 | Bookmark and Share


Enter your comment below



Leave a Reply

TORONTO BOOK PUBLISHING

Most Popular

Real Estate$500K is no longer enough to buy a new condo in Vancouver, survey finds

A national condo survey was unable to find any new condos selling for less than half a mill [...]

15 February 2018

Real EstateHome prices rise on gains in Vancouver, Victoria

Canada's housing market saw prices rise on a national basis in January, but the growth was almost [...]

15 February 2018

BusinessVancouver Airport Authority’s customs-kiosk business sets sail

Vancouver Airport Authority (VAA) last month notched a business breakthrough and what it calls a w [...]

20 February 2018

BusinessCanadian Cannabis Business Flies 100,000 Plants to Vancouver Amid Real Estate Shortage

As the start date for legal recreational weed in Canada looms near, cannabis startups are scramb [...]

20 February 2018

Toronto Walmart courts urban Vancouver customers with launch of fresh grocery delivery service

TORONTO — Walmart Canada Corp. is ramping up its food selling business in the West with the [...]

21 February 2018